This chapter examines the memory culture in German football, specifically the commemorative initiatives aimed at remembering Jewish club members. Through a detailed case study of FC Bayern Munich’s memory of Kurt Landauer, the article shows how collective memories are intrinsically linked to collective identities and how rewriting Jews into the history of German football had the side effect of forgetting about the perpetrators and collaborators. The chapter also highlights the emergence of two memory regimes in German football, those of the clubs and those of the fans. This case study cautions readers to consider the complex relationships between remembering and forgetting, memory and history, as well as memory and identity. The article concludes by emphasising the importance of thoroughly analysing and critically revising historical narratives.